a progressive motorcycle enthusiast organization
Dad of a fallen Marine perseveres against protests at military funerals
Washington – A father of a
son's funeral in 2006 – at least not until he hears from the US Supreme Court on the matter.
[Update from The Newsroom: Bill O'Reilly has offered to foot the bill.]
Albert Snyder, whose son, Lance Cpl. Matthew Snyder, was killed in Iraq, learned Friday that a is requiring him to pay more than $16,000 in legal fees to the , a Christian fundamentalist group that demonstrates during military funerals to gain attention for its antigovernment, antihomosexual message. The
group rallied at Matthew Snyder’s funeral in March 2006 in Westminster,
Md., chanting antigay slogans and carrying signs such as “Thank God for
dead soldiers,” says Albert Snyder’s attorney, Sean Summers.
The group was protesting about 30 feet from the church’s main entrance, and Mr. Snyder had to enter through a separate entrance, Mr. Summers says.
Snyder subsequently sued the Westboro group for emotional distress and won a $5 million judgment. But on appeal, the reversed, finding in favor of protecting the protesters' free-speech rights. About three weeks ago, the Supreme Court agreed to take the case and is expected to hear it in the fall. (Last
year, the high court had declined to take up the issue.) Meanwhile, the
circuit court has ordered Snyder, a salesman, to pay the church’s court
Snyder, of York, Pa., told Fox News on Tuesday that he would not pay the Westboro Baptist Church "until I hear from the Supreme Court."
“It’s fair to say that they are not getting any Christmas cards from Mr.
Snyder,” adds Summers, in a phone interview. “He obviously thinks they
are despicable and doesn’t understand why they would target him.”
The Westboro group has been protesting at military members’ funerals for years. The church leader, American deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan are punishment for the nation’s tolerance of homosexuality. (He was
among those banned from Britain last year for fostering hatred or
extremism.) The protests have nothing to do with the fallen service
members' sexual orientation, and the church says its protests are held
within a “lawful distance” of the funerals.
Ultimately, say some, the church protests are a matter of constitutionally protected free speech.
“I really don’t see that [the protest] was a violation of the First
Amendment [principles]. It was a violation of decorum and good taste
and all sorts of other things, but not a violation of the First Amendment,” says Charles Gittins, a civilian lawyer in Virginia.
But Summers argues that his client’s right to peaceful assembly and freedom of religion were infringed by the protests and that, unlike at a public park where
people are free to express themselves, a funeral setting draws a
“captive audience” that requires attendees to be in a particular
location – they can’t simply walk away.
Westboro Baptist Church, which is based in Kansas, plans to protest in Florida on Wednesday, outside a funeral for a Marine killed in Helmand Province in southern Afghanistan on March 22.
“Military funerals have become pagan orgies of idolatrous blasphemy, where they pray to
the dunghill gods of Sodom and play taps to a fallen fool,” states a
press release posted on the church’s website, announcing the rally at a
memorial service for Lance Cpl. Justin Wilson. At the bottom of the
press release are printed the words “Thank God for IEDs,” referring to
the roadside bombs that have killed thousands of troops in both wars.